By: Jeffrey Messing and Dalton Earich – It has been a busy season of personnel changes at the U.S. International Trade Commission.  On November 3, 2026, Chairman Brett W. Doyle announced that Lisa A. Murray and Benjamin S. Richards have been named the Commission’s newest Administrative Law Judges.  They join the bench following the September retirement of Judge McNamara.  Their appointments come just months after the Senate confirmed five new commissioners in July, restoring the Commission to its full six-member complement for the first time in nearly a decade.

Whether you are a seasoned Section 337 practitioner, a company that may one day bring or defend a case at the ITC, or simply someone curious about how the agency works, these changes matter because they reach both levels of the ITC’s decision-making.  ALJs manage the day-to-day litigation of each investigation, from discovery disputes through the evidentiary hearing and the initial determination.  The Commission then decides whether to review those determinations, issues exclusion orders, and sets the policy direction of the agency.  Below, we look first at the two new ALJs and then at the five commissioners who now make up the Commission, with an eye toward what their backgrounds may mean for parties appearing before the ITC.

Two New Administrative Law Judges[1]

As ALJs, the two judges will oversee Section 337 investigations from start to finish, running their own dockets, conducting evidentiary hearings, and writing the initial determinations that the Commission later reviews.  Most of these cases turn on claims that imported products infringe U.S. patents or trademarks.  Both judges arrive with deep experience in the ITC’s own Section 337 practice, which should allow them to take on a full docket with little ramp-up time.

Lisa A. Murray

Judge Murray is no stranger to the ITC.  For sixteen years, from 2008 to 2024, she worked in the Commission’s Office of Unfair Import Investigations (OUII), where, as a staff investigative attorney, she advocated for the public interest in Section 337 cases involving patents and trade secrets.  She then moved to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, sitting as an Administrative Patent Judge on the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) from 2024 until her selection this year.  Her legal career started with a clerkship for Chief Judge Dominick L. DiCarlo of the U.S. Court of International Trade, followed by private practice handling intellectual property and international trade matters.  Her academic credentials are unusually broad.  In addition to a law degree earned cum laude at the University of Michigan, she holds a master’s degree in computer science from the George Washington University, a master’s degree in political science from Michigan, and an undergraduate degree from Oberlin College, where she studied history and music performance.

Judge Murray’s résumé is notable on several fronts.  Her long tenure at OUII means she has seen Section 337 investigations from the inside, from the staff attorney’s vantage point of evaluating the public interest across a wide range of patent and trade secret disputes.  Her recent PTAB service adds fresh experience with patent validity questions, an issue that frequently runs in parallel with ITC investigations.  And her graduate training in computer science may prove valuable in the technology-heavy investigations that make up much of the docket.

Benjamin S. Richards

Judge Richards also knows the Commission well.  He held attorney-advisor positions in two ITC offices, the Office of the General Counsel and the Office of the Administrative Law Judges, counseling both the Commission and its ALJs on Section 337 matters and representing the Commission in appeals before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.  Earlier, he litigated patent, trademark, and copyright cases on behalf of the federal government as a trial attorney in the Intellectual Property Section of the Justice Department’s Civil Division.  Most recently, he was Of Counsel at Winston Taylor LLP in Washington, D.C.  A mathematics graduate of the University of Utah, he earned his law degree at the George Washington University Law School.

Judge Richards’s experience spans nearly every stage of a Section 337 matter.  Having advised ALJs on pending investigations, he knows the mechanics of the initial determination process firsthand.  His work in the Office of the General Counsel gives him insight into how the Commission reviews those determinations, and his Federal Circuit advocacy gives him a clear view of how they hold up on appeal.  Combined with his recent private-practice experience, that background should give him a well-rounded perspective on the practical realities facing both complainants and respondents.

*   *   *                                    *   *   *                                    * * *

Taken together, the two appointments bring seasoned Section 337 insiders to the bench at a time when the ITC docket remains active.  Parties with matters likely to be assigned to either judge should watch closely for their initial ground rules and early procedural orders, which will offer the first concrete signals of how each intends to manage discovery, claim construction, and hearing practice.

Five New Commissioners Join the Commission

The Commission is also at full strength for the first time in nearly a decade.  On July 16, 2026, the Senate confirmed five new commissioners by voice vote, ending years in which only three commissioners served, all on expired terms.  As Ranking Member Wyden put it at the confirmation hearing, the Commission had been “starting a soccer game with six players on the field.”[2]  The bipartisan slate—three Republicans (Brett Doyle, David Foley, Jr., and Peter-Anthony Pappas) and two Democrats (Bartholomew Thanhauser and Samuel Negatu)—moved quickly: the Finance Committee held a hearing on June 25, 2026, approved the nominations on July 14, and the full Senate confirmed them two days later.  A few months into their tenure, the commissioners’ backgrounds and stated priorities, highlighted below, offer meaningful signals about the agency’s direction.

Brett Doyle (R–Connecticut)[3] — Chairman

Brett Doyle, a Republican from Connecticut, was nominated on January 29, 2026, confirmed on July 16, sworn in on July 17, and designated Chairman on July 20.[4]  His term as commissioner runs through December 16, 2030, and his term as Chairman through June 16, 2028.[5]  His background is squarely in trade policy.  As Assistant U.S. Trade Representative for Congressional Affairs, he directed congressional engagement on trade negotiations, legislation, tariff policy, and enforcement.[6]  He also held roles at the EPA, the U.S. Senate, Sylvamo, and the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, and is a graduate of Lafayette College and the U.S. Naval War College.  In his confirmation testimony, Doyle traced his interest in trade to his upbringing in a small farming community in northwestern Connecticut, once a manufacturing powerhouse producing clocks, rubber, brass, and small arms, whose industrial base has “declined precipitously” over the past fifty years.[7]  He told the Committee that “trade is not an abstraction: the location and concentration of industry and employment are what shape our communities.  It is the duty of the government to defend American enterprise from unfair trade practices.”[8]  In his written responses, Doyle stated that “illegal transshipment and intentional circumvention of legitimate AD/CVD orders are significant problems that require greater attention by the Commission.”[9]  He also acknowledged concerns that certain ITC economic models may be “materially deficient,” and committed to supporting adverse inferences against non-cooperating foreign producers “in a manner consistent with the law.”[10]  Together, these responses suggest a strong interest in protecting domestic industries.

David Foley, Jr. (R–Virginia)[11]

David Foley, Jr., a Republican from Virginia, brings perhaps the most IP-litigation-specific credentials of the five.  An electrical engineer by training, Foley turned to law after watching the tech bubble burst and entered private practice as an IP litigator.[12]  In 2012, he left private practice for a two-year clerkship in the ITC’s Office of the Administrative Law Judges, which launched a career in government service.  He went on to serve in the DOJ’s Commercial Litigation Branch, on detail to the Executive Office of the President on international trade issues, as an Attorney Advisor in the USPTO’s Office of Policy and International Affairs, where he focused on enforcement against illicit trade originating in China, and most recently as Chief Counsel for the House Judiciary Committee.[13]  He was also commissioned in the U.S. Air Force Reserve JAG Corps in 2019 and attended the National Intelligence University.  In his Senate testimony, Foley drew a direct line between military service and trade enforcement: “[h]aving served alongside the men and women who form the backbone of the world’s greatest Air Force, I understand the human stakes and the direct impact our supply chains have on our military and its readiness.”[14]  He noted that in fiscal year 2025, CBP seized more than $7.4 billion in counterfeit goods, “the overwhelming majority of which, by value, came from the PRC and Hong Kong.”[15]  Foley also committed to “fully participating in the review of public comments” on the Commission’s proposed rulemaking on Section 337 disclosure of ownership and financial interests, published April 30, 2026.[16]

Peter-Anthony Pappas (R–New Jersey)[17]

Peter-Anthony Pappas, a Republican from New Jersey, was sworn in on August 3, 2026, and holds the longest term of the five, extending through June 2035.  He holds a B.S. in Computer Engineering from Georgia Tech and an Executive Certificate in Public Leadership from the Harvard Kennedy School.  Before joining the Commission, Pappas served as Director of Intellectual Property Policy for the Senate Judiciary Committee under Senator Thom Tillis.  Before that, he spent over twenty years at the USPTO, rising from Patent Examiner to Primary Patent Examiner, Supervisory Patent Examiner, PTAB Branch Chief Detailee, and Special Advisor to then-Director Andrei Iancu, in which role he helped develop the influential 2019 Revised Patent Subject Matter Eligibility Guidance.[18]  He thus brings unusual depth of patent-prosecution knowledge to the Commission.  In his testimony, Pappas rooted intellectual property in America’s founding: “Article I, Section 8, Clause 8, of the U.S. Constitution grants Congress the enumerated power ‘To promote the progress of science and useful arts.’ … How many other countries had the foresight to embed intellectual property into their very founding?”[19]  He emphasized that “[s]trong, clear, reliable, and predictable IP rights drive investments to innovative technologies and these rights encourage the creation of content that the world consumes.”[20]  In his written answers, Pappas explained how the automatic stay under 28 U.S.C. § 1659 preserves judicial economy where Section 337 and district court litigation overlap.[21]  He called transshipment and “country-hopping” tactics “well-known trade evasion tactics used to bypass AD/CVD orders” that “must be addressed.”[22]  On foreign adversaries, he stated that “[f]oreign adversaries, such as the Chinese Communist Party, threaten U.S. economic and innovation dominance through rampant intellectual property theft and abuse.  This abuse includes gamesmanship of the U.S. legal system and this abuse must be addressed.”[23]

Bartholomew Thanhauser (D–New York)[24]

Bartholomew Thanhauser, a Democrat from New York, brings a trade negotiator’s perspective to the Commission.  Nominated by President Trump on June 1, 2026, he has the shortest term of the five, expiring in December 2027.  He spent more than a decade at the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative, including as Deputy Assistant USTR for Southeast Asia and the Pacific, and served as a Legislative Fellow and Trade Advisor to Senator Catherine Cortez Masto, working on critical minerals and agriculture issues.  He holds a B.A. from Cornell University and an M.A. in International Economics from Johns Hopkins SAIS.  In his testimony, Thanhauser placed the ITC’s work in historical context, noting that “Congress created the ITC over a century ago, in the midst of the First World War,” and that President Woodrow Wilson argued the Commission was needed as “another eye … to see the facts.”[25]  He described nearly a decade and a half as a trade negotiator, “pressing our trading partners to raise their labor and environmental standards so that U.S. workers and firms can compete on a level playing field.”[26]  He also spoke to trade’s human cost, noting that much of his wife’s family “worked in textiles manufacturing in Puerto Rico and the Bronx throughout the 1980s and 90s,” and that “[t]he economic disruption of losing a job and finding a new profession was very challenging.”[27]  Most notably for practitioners, Thanhauser gave the strongest signal of any nominee on adverse inferences: “[y]es, if confirmed, I would fully support the application of adverse inferences if foreign producers do not cooperate with the Commission’s investigations or reviews to the fullest extent allowed under the law.”[28]

Samuel Negatu (D–District of Columbia)

Samuel Negatu, a Democrat from the District of Columbia, is the son of Ethiopian immigrants whose pursuit of the American dream, he told the Committee, made it possible “for their son to sit before this Committee today.”[29]  Negatu served on Capitol Hill in the offices of Representatives Matt Cartwright and Jimmy Gomez, was a staff negotiator for the USMCA working group on labor issues, served at USTR as Deputy Assistant USTR for Congressional Affairs and then Assistant General Counsel, and most recently was Director of Government and Regulatory Affairs at the Consumer Technology Association.  He holds a B.A. in Political Science from UC Santa Barbara and a J.D. from Washington University in St. Louis School of Law.  Negatu’s testimony emphasized independence and institutional fidelity: “[m]y duty would be to evaluate each matter based solely on the record before the Commission and to apply the law as enacted by Congress.”[30]  In his written responses, he took a measured approach to adverse inferences, noting that “Congress authorized the Commission to apply adverse inferences in appropriate circumstances” while cautioning that “the Commission must consider the effect that adverse inferences may have on the overall record and on parties that have fully cooperated.”[31]  He also stressed that the “Commission’s credibility depends on the quality, rigor, and objectivity of its economic analysis” and committed to continuing to “refine its analytical tools, data sources, and methodologies.”[32]

What It All Means

The confirmation of five commissioners in a single vote was a rare institutional moment for the ITC, and the arrival of two experienced ALJs rounds out a significant year of turnover.  With Doyle at the helm, Pappas’s deep patent expertise locked in through 2035, bipartisan consensus on circumvention and enforcement, and multiple commissioners openly signaling interest in adverse inferences, economic methodology reform, and Section 337 procedural transparency, this is shaping up to be a consequential period for the agency.  Add two new judges with extensive Section 337 experience, and the message for complainants and respondents alike is the same: prepare for an ITC that is fully staffed and potentially more active than it has been in years.

[1] Press Release, U.S. Int’l Trade Comm’n, USITC to Appoint Lisa Murray and Benjamin Richards as New Administrative Law Judges, No. 26-155 (November 3, 2026), https://www.usitc.gov/press_room/news_release/2026/er1103_69464.htm.

[2]Ranking Member Ron Wyden, Opening Statement at Senate Finance Committee Hearing on ITC Nominees (June 25, 2026).

[3] Commissioner Doyle’s bio can be located here: https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/doyle.

[4]Press Release, U.S. Int’l Trade Comm’n, Brett Doyle Sworn In as Commissioner and Designated Chairman of the U.S. International Trade Commission (July 2026); Hearing to Consider the Nominations of Brett Doyle et al., S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[5] Chairman Brett W. Doyle, United States International Trade Commission, https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/doyle (July 21, 2026).

[6]Statement of Brett Doyle Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[7]Id.

[8]Id.

[9]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Brett Doyle from Senator Cassidy, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 4 (June 25, 2026).

[10]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Brett Doyle from Senator Warren, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Questions 5(a) & 12 (June 25, 2026).

[11] Commissioner Foley’s bio can be located here: https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/foley_jr.

[12]Opening Statement of David Allen Foley, Jr. Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[13]  Commissioner David Foley, Jr., United States International Trade Commission, https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/foley_jr (August 17, 2026).

[14]Opening Statement of David Allen Foley, Jr. Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[15]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to David Foley, Jr. from Senator Blackburn, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 1 (June 25, 2026).

[16]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to David Foley, Jr. from Senator Warnock, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Questions 5–6 (June 25, 2026).

[17] Commissioner Pappas’s bio can be found here: https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/pappas.

[18]Testimony of Peter-Anthony Pappas Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[19]Id.

[20]Id.

[21]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Peter-Anthony Pappas from Senator Blackburn, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 1 (June 25, 2026).

[22]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Peter-Anthony Pappas from Senator Cassidy, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 4 (June 25, 2026).

[23]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Peter-Anthony Pappas from Senator Cassidy, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 2 (June 25, 2026).

[24] Commissioner Thanhauser’s bio can be located here: https://www.usitc.gov/about/commissioners/bios/thanhauser.

[25]Opening Statement of Bartholomew Thanhauser Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[26]Id.

[27]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Bartholomew Thanhauser from Senator Warren, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 8 (June 25, 2026).

[28]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Bartholomew Thanhauser from Senator Warren, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 5(a) (June 25, 2026).

[29]Statement of Samuel T. Negatu Before the S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong. (June 25, 2026).

[30]Id.

[31]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Samuel Negatu from Senator Warren, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 5(a) (June 25, 2026).

[32]Responses to Questions for the Record Submitted to Samuel Negatu from Senator Warren, S. Comm. on Finance, 119th Cong., Question 12 (June 25, 2026).

The following two tabs change content below.
Jeff Messing represents domestic and international companies on a variety of intellectual property matters, with a primary focus on patent litigation before the International Trade Commission (ITC), U.S. district courts across the country, and post-grant proceedings at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO). Jeff's litigation experience spans a variety of technologies across multiple industries such as pharmaceuticals, telecommunications, semiconductors, batteries, electronic circuits, medical devices, child care, and LED lighting devices. Jeff has extensive experience in all phases of litigation, from pretrial investigations through appeal. Jeff has managed discovery practice in district court trials and in several ITC investigations and acted as a key trial team member in several ITC evidentiary hearings and district court trials. Jeff has extensive experience in coordinating discovery, taking fact and expert depositions, preparing motions, and preparing pre- and post-trial briefing. He has worked with numerous fact and expert witnesses through discovery and trial/final hearing in matters before the ITC, U.S. district courts, and the USPTO. Jeff maintains an active pro bono practice and represents tenants facing eviction. He also has experience in applications, manufacturing, and MEP (mechanical, electrical, and plumbing) engineering gained from working during his undergraduate education.